California Drunk Driving Defense

Table of Contents

  • Preface
  • Comment
  • Acknowledgements
  • About the Author
  • Part One - Crime and Punishment
  • Chapter 1 - The Offense
  • I. Generally
  • §1:1
    The corpus
  • §1:2
    "Drive"
  • §1:3
    "Vehicle"
  • II. Under the Influence
  • A. Under the Influence of Alcohol (Veh C § 23152 (a))
  • §1:4
    In general
  • §1:5
    "Under the Influence" defined
  • §1:6
    Blood-alcohol presumptions
  • B. Over .08% Blood Alcohol Content (Veh C § 23152 (b))
  • §1:7
    In genera
  • §1:8
    Juveniles under 21 with .05% blood-alcohol content
  • §1:9
    Commercial driver with .04% blood-alcohol content
  • C. Under the Influence of Drugs (Veh C § 23152 (a))
  • §1:10
    In general
  • §1:11
    Driving while addicted: Veh C § 23152 (c)
  • III Felony Drunk Driving (Veh C § 23153 (a) and (b))
  • §1:12
    In general
  • §1:13
    Vehicular manslaughter
  • §1:14
    Murder: Watson
  • §1:15
    "Three strikes": Veh C § 23152 with three priors
  • IV. Other Grounds of Liability
  • §1:16
    Attempted drunk driving
  • §1:17
    Accomplice liability
  • V. Defenses
  • §1:18
    In general
  • §1:19
    Double jeopardy
  • §1:20
    Mistake of fact
  • §1:21
    Necessity and duress
  • §1:22
    Entrapment
  • §1:23
    Insanity
  • Chapter 2 - The Sentence
  • I. The Misdemeanor (Veh C § 23152)
  • §2:1
    In general
  • §2:2
    License suspension/restriction
  • §2:3
    DUI school
  • §2:4
    Ignition interlocks
  • §2:5
    Impound and sale of vehicle
  • II. The Felony (Veh C § 23153)
  • §2:6
    In general
  • §2:7
    "Three strikes"
  • §2:8
    Manslaughter and murder
  • III. Sentence Enhancements
  • §2:9
    In general
  • §2:10
    Prior convictions (Veh C § 23152)
  • §2:11
    Prior convictions (Veh C § 23153)
  • §2:12
    Refusal
  • §2:13
    Reckless speeding
  • §2:14
    Child endangerment
  • §2:15
    Over .20% blood-alcohol content
  • §2:16
    Multiple victims
  • IV. Sentencing Issues
  • §2:17
    In general
  • §2:18
    Multiple punishment
  • §2:19
    Defendant's perjury at trial
  • §2:20
    Work furlough
  • §2:21
    Community service and work release
  • §2:22
    Residential alcohol treatment
  • §2:23
    Electronic home detection
  • V. Probation Violatoin
  • §2:24
    In general
  • Part Two - License Suspensions and the DMV
  • Chapter 3 - Administrative Suspension
  • §3:1
    In general
  • §3:2
    Drivers under 21: "zero tolerance"
  • II. Refusal To submit to chemical Test
  • §3:3
    In general
  • §3:4
    What constitutes a refusal
  • III. Double Jeopardy and Collateral Estoppel
  • §3:5
    In general
  • Chapter 4 - The DMV Hearing
  • I. Pretrial Procedures
  • §4:1
    In general
  • §4:2
    Discovery and the subpoena
  • II. Hearing Procedures
  • §4:3
    In general
  • §4:4
    Rules of evidence
  • III. Administrative and Judicial Review
  • §4:5
    In general
  • Part Three - Pretrial
  • Chapter 5 - Interview and Arraignment
  • I. Generally
  • §5:1
    The midnight phone call
  • II. The Client Interview
  • §5:2
    In general
  • §5:3
    Educating the client
  • §5:4
    The retainer agreement
  • III. The Arraignment
  • §5:5
    general
  • §5:6
    Plea of "once in jeopardy" (DMV suspension)
  • IV. Evaluating and Plea Bargaining the Case
  • §5:7
    In general; evaluating the case
  • §5:8
    Plea bargaining
  • Chapter 6 - Discovery
  • I. Generally
  • §6:1
    In general
  • §6:2
    Police evidence
  • II. Blood-Alcohol Evidence
  • §6:3
    In general
  • §6:4
    Obtaining blood or urine sample
  • §6:5
    Obtaining court-ordered analysis and expert testimony
  • §6:6
    Sample discovery motion
  • III. Using the DMV Hearing
  • §6:7
    For deposing the officer
  • Chapter 7 - Prior Convictions
  • I. Generally
  • §7:1
    In general
  • II. Procedure
  • A. Factual Requirements
  • §7:2
    In general
  • §7:3
    Bifurcation of trial
  • B. Legal Requirements
  • §7:4
    In general; moving to strike the prior
  • §7:5
    Constitutional grounds
  • §7:6
    Procedural requirements
  • §7:7
    The record
  • III. Issues as to Specific Priors
  • §7:8
    Uncharged priors
  • §7:9
    The uncounselled prior
  • §7:10
    The juvenile prior
  • §7:11
    Foreign priors
  • §7:12
    Incompetence of prior counsel
  • §7:13
    Sample motion to strike prior conviction
  • Chapter 8 - Suppression of Evidence
  • I. Generally
  • §8:1
    In general
  • II. Stop, Detention and Arrest
  • §8:2
    In generally; probable cause
  • §8:3
    Sobriety checkpoints
  • §8:4
    Authority to arrest: driving in officer's presence
  • III. Incriminating Statements
  • §8:5
    In general; Miranda-Berkemer
  • §8:6
    The corpus rule
  • §8:7
    Refusal to take chemical test
  • IV. Field Sobriety Tests
  • §8:8
    In general; Kelley-Frye
  • §8:9
    Mental acuity tests: Muniz
  • §8:10
    Nystagmus
  • §8:11
    Pupil reaction
  • §8:12
    Preliminary breath tests (PBT)
  • §8:13
    Police obstruction of witnesses
  • §8:14
    Tapes, film and photographs
  • V. Blood-Alcohol Evidence
  • §8:15
    In general
  • §8:16
    Defective implied consent and advisement
  • §8:17
    Denial of access to counsel
  • §8:18
    Forceful seizure: Schmerber
  • §8:19
    Denial of independent sample
  • §8:20
    Chain of custody
  • §8:21
    Lack of foundation: Title 17
  • §8:22
    Failure to provide discovery
  • Part Four - Trial
  • Chapter 9 - Jury Selection and Opening Statement
  • I. Jury Selectoin
  • §9:1 In general
  • §9:2
    Illustrative jury voir dire
  • §9:3
    Sample proposed questions
  • §9:4
    Discovery of prosecution records on jurors
  • II. Opening Statement
  • §9:5
    In general; illustration
  • Chapter 10 - Field Evidence: The Arresting Officer
  • I. Generally
  • A. Generally
  • §10:1
    In general; field evidence and the arresting officer
  • §10:2
    The officer as intoxication expert
  • §10:3
    Preparation
  • §10:4
    Strategy
  • B. Officer's Background and Experience
  • §10:5
    General techniques
  • §10:6
    Officer's training and experience
  • II. Driving Symptoms
  • §10:7
    In general
  • §10:8
    The NHTSA studies
  • III. Physical Symptoms
  • §10:9
    In general
  • §10:10
    Appearance and conduct
  • §10:11
    Odor of alcohol on breath
  • §10:12
    Flushed face
  • §10:13
    Bloodshot eyes
  • §10:14
    Slurred speech
  • §10:15
    The effects of hypoglycemia
  • IV. Field Sobriety Tests
  • A. Generally
  • §10:16
    In general
  • §10:17
    Performance tests
  • §10:18
    Objective scoring
  • §10:19
    Kelley-Frye and standardized field sobriety tests
  • §10:20
    The NHTSA tests
  • B. Eye Impairment Tests
  • §10:21
    In general; pupil reaction
  • §10:22
    Horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN)
  • §10:23
    Illustrative cross-examination on nystagmus
  • V. Preliminary Breath Tests
  • §10:24
    In general
  • VI. Special Cross-Examination Techniques
  • §10:25
    In general
  • §10:26
    The infallible cop
  • §10:27
    Selective recall
  • §10:28
    The wedge
  • §10:29
    The magic memory
  • §10:30
    Carbon-copy symptoms
  • §10:31
    The disappearing sway
  • §10:32
    The negative pregnant
  • §10:33
    Reverse impairment
  • §10:34
    The rigged scoreboard
  • §10:35
    The bomb
  • §10:36
    Field evidence and the arresting officer
  • VII. Defense Police Expert
  • §10:37
    In general
  • Chapter 11 - Chemical Evidence: The Forensic Chemist
  • I. Generally; Blood-Alcohol Analysis
  • §11:1
    In general
  • §11:2
    Blood-alcohol absorption
  • §11:3
    The fallacy of the average person
  • §11:4
    Individual tolerance
  • §11:5
    Women and alcohol
  • §11:6
    The rising blood-alcohol concentration (BAC) curve
  • §11:7
    Retrograde extrapolation
  • §11:8
    Food, cigarettes and alcohol metabolism
  • §11:9
    The zinc factor
  • §11:10
    Internally produced alcohol
  • §11:11
    Radio frequency interference (RFI)
  • §11:12
    Inherent error
  • II. Breath Analysis
  • A. Generally
  • §11:13
    In general
  • §11:14
    The blood-breath partition ratio
  • §11:15
    Nonspecific analysis
  • §11:16
    Testing during the absorptive state
  • §11:17
    Mouth alcohol
  • §11:18
    Hematocrit
  • §11:19
    Body temperature
  • §11:20
    Breathing pattern
  • §11:21
    Stress
  • §11:22
    Simulator calibration
  • §11:23
    Ambient air
  • B. Breath Analysis Machines
  • §11:24
    In general
  • §11:25
    The Intoxilyzer 5000
  • §11:26
    The Intoximeter 3000
  • III. Blood Analysis
  • §11:27
    In general
  • §11:28
    Sterilization
  • §11:29
    Fermentation
  • §11:30
    Whole blood vs. serum/plasma
  • §11:31
    Arterial vs. venous blood
  • IV. Urinalysis
  • §11:32
    In general
  • §11:33
    The urine:blood ratio
  • §11:34
    The incomplete void
  • §11:35
    Candida albicans
  • V. Cross-Examination Techniques
  • A. Generally
  • §11:36
    In general
  • §11:37
    The smart machine
  • §11:38
    The spiked aspirin
  • §11:39
    Close enough for government work
  • §11:40
    How infrared works — and why it doesn't
  • §11:41
    The defective warranty
  • §11:42
    RFI magic
  • §11:43
    A ton of beer
  • §11:44
    The invisible breath sample
  • §11:45
    Wonder blood
  • §11:46
    Purple urine
  • B. Illustrative Cross-Examination of Expert
  • §11:47
    In general
  • §11:48
    Transcript of cross-examination of an expert
  • §11:49
    Illustrative cross-examination of Intoxilyzer operator
  • VI. The Defense Blood-Alcohol Expert
  • §11:50
    In general
  • §11:51
    Preparing the defense expert for cross-examination
  • §11:52
    Illustrative direct examination of defense expert
  • Chapter 12 - The Lay Witness; Defendant Witness
  • I. Generally; Percipient Witness
  • §12:1
    In general
  • §12:2
    Lay opinion of intoxication
  • §12:3
    Illustrative cross-examination of percipient witness
  • II. Sobriety Witness
  • §12:4
    In general
  • §12:5
    Preparing the sobriety witness for cross-examination
  • §12:6
    Illustrative direct examination of sobriety witness
  • III. Defendant
  • §12:7
    In general; should the defendant testify?
  • §12:8
    Preparing the defendant
  • §12:9
    Illustrative direct examination of defendant
  • Chapter 13 - Jury Instructions and Argument
  • §13:1
    Jury instructions
  • §13:2
    CALJIC instructions
  • §13:3
    Closing argument
  •  
    • Bibliography
    • Table of Statutes
    • Table of Cases
    • Index
Back to Top

Offices Located In


  • Rancho Cucamonga 8608 Utica Avenue, Suite 220, Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730 909.689.4515
  • Huntington Beach 16152 Beach Blvd, Suite 280, Huntington Beach, CA 92647 562.989.4774
  • Irvine 19800 Macarthur Boulevard #300, Irvine, CA 92612 949.752.1550
  • Long Beach 3780 Kilroy Airport Way #200, Long Beach, CA 90806 562.989.4774
  • Riverside 7121 Magnolia Avenue Suite H, Riverside, CA 92504 951.369.4999
  • Orange 1045 West Katella Avenue #350, Orange, CA 92867 714.716.2589
  • Torrance 21515 Hawthorne Boulevard Suite 200, Torrance, CA 90503 424.271.0490
  • Beverly Hills 468 N. Camden Drive, Second Floor, La Colonade Building, Beverly Hills, CA 90210 310.746.1960

Call or email the Firm’s founder, Lawrence Taylor, or our Managing Attorney, Chris Taylor, for a free consultation.